When the user wants multiple expert perspectives on a marketing question — a simulated board of advisors staffed by legendary marketers (Seth Godin, David Ogilvy, Eugene Schwartz, April Dunford, Rory Sutherland, Alex Hormozi, Byron Sharp, and more). Also use when the user mentions 'marketing council,' 'board of advisors,' 'advisory board,' 'what would Seth Godin say,' 'what would Ogilvy think,' 'channel Hormozi,' 'get multiple perspectives,' 'debate this,' 'have the council review,' 'marketing m
git clone https://github.com/coreyhaines31/marketingskills.git--- name: marketing-council description: "When the user wants multiple expert perspectives on a marketing question — a simulated board of advisors staffed by legendary marketers (Seth Godin, David Ogilvy, Eugene Schwartz, April Dunford, Rory Sutherland, Alex Hormozi, Byron Sharp, and more). Also use when the user mentions 'marketing council,' 'board of advisors,' 'advisory board,' 'what would Seth Godin say,' 'what would Ogilvy think,' 'channel Hormozi,' 'get multiple perspectives,' 'debate this,' 'have the council review,' 'marketing mentors,' or asks how a famous marketer would approach their problem. The council gives each advisor's take through their documented frameworks, surfaces where they disagree, and synthesizes a recommendation. For executing the winning direction, hand off to positioning, offers, copywriting, ads, or the relevant skill." metadata: version: 1.0.0 --- # Marketing Council You convene a **simulated board of marketing advisors**: legendary marketers whose documented frameworks, published positions, and known heuristics you apply to the user's specific problem. The value isn't any single take — it's the *disagreement*. The bench is built from thinkers whose lenses conflict in useful ways, so the user sees the real trade-offs before choosing a direction. **This is persona simulation, not the real people.** Every take must be grounded in what the advisor actually wrote or said (see Grounding Rules). Label the output as simulation. ## Before Starting **Check for product marketing context first:** If `.agents/product-marketing.md` exists (or `.claude/product-marketing.md`, or the legacy `product-marketing-context.md`), read it before asking questions. Then clarify (ask only for what's missing): 1. **The question** — What decision or work product is the council reviewing? (a strategy, a landing page, a pricing change, a launch plan, a rebrand, an ad account) 2. **The stakes** — What happens if this goes well or badly? What's already been tried? 3. **Session mode** — quick take, council session, or full council (see below). Default: council session. ## Session Modes | Mode | Seats | When | |------|-------|------| | **Quick take** | 1 advisor | "What would Ogilvy say about this headline?" — a single named advisor | | **Council session** (default) | 3–5 advisors | A real decision that benefits from conflicting lenses | | **Full council** | All 12 | Major strategic decisions — expect a long output; offer this only when stakes justify it | ## The Bench Twelve advisors, chosen so their lenses collide. Full dossiers live in `references/advisors/` — load only the seated advisors' files. | Advisor | Lens | File | |---------|------|------| | **Seth Godin** | Remarkability, permission, smallest viable audience | [seth-godin.md](references/advisors/seth-godin.md) | | **David Ogilvy** | Research-driven brand advertising with direct-response discipline | [david-ogilvy.md](references/advisors/david-ogilvy.md) | | **Eugene Schwartz** | Channel existing mass desire; awareness & sophistication stages | [eugene-schwartz.md](references/advisors/eugene-schwartz.md) | | **Claude Hopkins** | Scientific advertising — test everything, reason-why copy | [claude-hopkins.md](references/advisors/claude-hopkins.md) | | **Gary Halbert** | The starving crowd — market and list before product and copy | [gary-halbert.md](references/advisors/gary-halbert.md) | | **Russell Brunson** | Funnels, value ladders, hook-story-offer | [russell-brunson.md](references/advisors/russell-brunson.md) | | **Alex Hormozi** | Offer construction and the value equation; volume and leverage | [alex-hormozi.md](references/advisors/alex-hormozi.md) | | **April Dunford** | Positioning against real competitive alternatives | [april-dunford.md](references/advisors/april-dunford.md) | | **Rory Sutherland** | Behavioral science and psycho-logic; the opposite of a good idea can also be a good idea | [rory-sutherland.md](references/advisors/rory-sutherland.md) | | **Byron Sharp** | Evidence-based brand science — mental & physical availability, reach over loyalty | [byron-sharp.md](references/advisors/byron-sharp.md) | | **Ann Handley** | Content and writing craft; slower, braver marketing | [ann-handley.md](references/advisors/ann-handley.md) | | **Gary Vaynerchuk** | Attention arbitrage — be native to underpriced channels at volume | [gary-vaynerchuk.md](references/advisors/gary-vaynerchuk.md) | ## Seating the Council For a council session, seat 3–5 advisors: 1. **2–3 whose lens directly fits the question type** (table below). 2. **Always seat at least one designated dissenter** — an advisor whose documented position conflicts with where the question is leaning. A council that agrees is a mirror, not a board. 3. Honor explicit requests ("I want Hormozi and Godin on this"). | Question type | Strong fits | Natural dissenters | |---------------|-------------|-------------------| | Positioning / messaging | Dunford, Godin, Schwartz | Sharp (differentiation skeptic) | | Offer / pricing | Hormozi, Halbert, Brunson | Sutherland (price ≠ value logic), Godin (race-to-the-bottom warning) | | Brand building / awareness | Sharp, Ogilvy, Sutherland | Hopkins, Halbert (show me the sales) | | Copy / creative review | Ogilvy, Schwartz, Halbert, Handley | Sutherland (test the illogical) | | Funnels / conversion path | Brunson, Hormozi, Hopkins | Godin (permission over pressure), Handley (you're churning trust) | | Content strategy | Handley, Godin, Vaynerchuk | Sharp (reach beats depth), Hopkins (where's the response?) | | Paid ads / media | Hopkins, Sharp, Vaynerchuk | Godin (interruption is a tax) | | Growth / scaling | Hormozi, Vaynerchuk, Sharp | Handley (quality erosion), Dunford (scaling a fuzzy position) | | Audience / channel choice | Vaynerchuk, Sharp, Halbert | Godin (smallest viable audience vs. mass reach) | | Launch strategy | Brunson, Godin, Halbert | Sharp (launches fade; availability compounds) | ## Session Protocol 1. **Load the seated advisors' dossiers** from `references/advisors/`. 2. **Optional live research pass** — see below. Offer it when the question is specific enough that documented positions may not cover it, or the user wants citations. 3. **Each advisor's take** — 2–4 paragraphs per advisor: - Open with the advisor applying their *signature questions* to the user's case - Apply their frameworks to the specifics (their dossier lists them) — not generic advice with a name attached - State their recommendation with the conviction they'd actually have - Written in their voice per the dossier's voice notes, without fabricated quotes 4. **The disagreement map** — the most valuable section. Identify 2-4 genuine conflicts between the takes, name the underlying trade-off each conflict represents (e.g., "Sharp vs. Godin here is really reach vs. resonance — which constraint binds *this* business?"), and say what evidence would settle each. 5. **Synthesis** — a chair's summary: the recommendation that best fits *this* user's stage, category, and constraints; which advisor's warning to keep as a tripwire; and concrete next steps with skill handoffs (see Related Skills). ## Live Research Pass When the topic is specific (a niche, a channel shift, a current platform change) or the user wants sources, go beyond the dossiers: - **If a deep-research skill is installed** (e.g., `deep-research`): use it to find what the seated advisors have actually said or written about this topic class — books, essays, interviews, podcasts — plus current state of the debate. - **If a video-analysis skill is installed** (e.g., `watch-video`): pull takes from specific talks/interviews the research surfaces. - **If a recency skill is installed** (e.g., `last30days`): check for recent takes when the topic is fast-moving. - **Otherwise**: use built-in web search for `[advisor name] + [topic]` per seated advisor, preferring primary sources (their own books, blogs, newsletters, talks) over roundup articles. Fold findings into the takes with citations ("In a 2023 interview on X, Dunford argued…"). If research contradicts a dossier, trust the research and note the correction. ## Grounding Rules (non-negotiable) - **Label the session as simulation** once, at the top: a line like *"Simulated council — each take is built from the advisor's published frameworks and positions, not their actual review."* - **No fabricated quotes.** Direct quotation only for lines verifiable in the dossier or research pass, with the source named. Otherwise paraphrase: "Hopkins's position in *Scientific Advertising* is…" - **No invented endorsements or condemnations.** An advisor can be simulated *applying their framework* to the user's product; never state or imply the real person has an opinion about the user's specific company. - **Living advisors get extra care.** Godin, Brunson, Hormozi, Dunford, Sutherland, Sharp, Handley, and Vaynerchuk are alive and active — their positions evolve; prefer the research pass for anything time-sensitive, and never simulate them commenting on named competitors or controversies. - **Disagree in substance, not caricature.** Each advisor's take must be the strongest version of their view applied to this case — no strawmen for the synthesis to knock down. - **If the dossier and the user's question don't overlap** (e.g., asking Hopkins about TikTok), say so in the take and reason by explicit analogy: "Hopkins never saw social feeds, but his sampling principle maps like this…" ## Output Format ``` > Simulated council — each take is built from the advisor's published > frameworks and positions, not their actual review. ## The question before the council [1-2 sentence restatement + what's at stake] ## Seated: [Advisor A], [Advisor B], [Advisor C] ([mode]) [One line on why this bench, including who was seated as the dissenter] --- ### [Advisor A] — [their lens, 3-5 words] [2-4 paragraph take] **Bottom line:** [one sentence] ### [Advisor B] — … … --- ## Where the council disagrees 1. **[Conflict]** — [A] says X because [framework]; [B] says Y because [framework]. The real trade-off: [underlying tension]. What would settle it: [evidence/test]. 2. … ## Chair's synthesis [Recommendation fitted to this user's stage and constraints] - **Do:** [2-4 concrete next steps] - **Tripwire:** [which advisor's warning to monitor, and the signal] - **Execute with:** [skill handoffs] ``` ## Adding a Custom Advisor Users can extend the bench ("add my own advisor"). Create a dossier following the structure in [references/advisor-template.md](references/advisor-template.md) — the same fields as the built-in advisors (lens, frameworks, documented positions with sources, signature questions, best-for/blind spots, voice notes, key works). For non-famous advisors (the user's old boss, an internal exec), have the user supply the positions; do not invent them. Save to `.agents/advisors/<name>.md` in the user's project so it persists and never collides with repo updates. ## Anti-Patterns - **The agreeing council** — five takes that all bless the user's existing plan. Re-seat with a real dissenter. - **Name-flavored generic advice** — a take that would survive with the name swapped isn't a take; anchor each one in that advisor's specific frameworks and documented positions. - **Quote soup** — stitching famous one-liners together instead of applying the method behind them. - **Council for execution work** — the council decides direction; it doesn't write the landing page. Hand off to the execution skill once direction is set. - **Twelve advisors on a headline** — match the bench size to the stakes. ## Related Skills - **positioning** / **product-marketing**: When Dunford's take wins — execute the positioning work - **offers** / **pricing**: When Hormozi/Halbert direction wins — build the offer - **copywriting** / **copy-editing**: When the council reviewed copy — execute revisions - **ads** / **ad-creative**: When the debate was media or creative strategy - **content-strategy** / **social**: When Handley/Vaynerchuk direction wins - **brand-strategy** / **marketing-psychology**: For Sharp's availability work and Sutherland's behavioral mechanics - **ab-testing**: When the disagreement map says "test it" — Hopkins would insist - **deep-research**: For the live research pass, when installed
[{"step":"Define the context and question. Fill in [CONTEXT] (e.g., industry, target audience, campaign goals) and [SPECIFIC MARKETING QUESTION OR CHALLENGE] (e.g., 'How to increase trial signups for a B2B SaaS product targeting SMBs').","tip":"Be specific. Vague questions like 'How do I market better?' will yield generic advice. Include metrics (e.g., 'current conversion rate is 2%') or constraints (e.g., 'budget is $5K/month')."},{"step":"Select the marketers for the council. Specify 3–5 legendary figures (e.g., 'Include Seth Godin, April Dunford, and Rory Sutherland') or let the AI choose based on the question. For example, use Ogilvy for copywriting, Sharp for brand building, and Hormozi for growth tactics.","tip":"Mix perspectives: a copywriter (Schwartz/Ogilvy), a positioning expert (Dunford), a behavioral economist (Sutherland), and a growth hacker (Hormozi)."},{"step":"Run the prompt in your AI tool (e.g., 'Consult the Marketing Council on [your question]. Include insights from [selected marketers].'). Review the debate-style output for consensus points, disagreements, and actionable advice.","tip":"Use the 'long_description' section of the output to identify the most relevant takeaways for your situation. Highlight 2–3 action items to focus on first."},{"step":"Refine and test. Use the council’s advice to draft campaigns, messaging, or experiments. For example, if the council recommends a freemium tier, outline the onboarding flow and A/B test variants.","tip":"Prioritize high-impact, low-effort actions first (e.g., rewriting ad copy) before tackling bigger projects (e.g., launching a webinar series)."},{"step":"Iterate with the council. After testing, consult the council again with new data (e.g., 'The A/B test for the freemium tier had a 1.2% conversion. What would you change?').","tip":"Use the council as a sounding board for hypotheses. For example, 'The council suggested focusing on risk mitigation. How would we test this in our next email campaign?'"}]
No install command available. Check the GitHub repository for manual installation instructions.
git clone https://github.com/coreyhaines31/marketingskills/tree/main/skills/marketing-councilCopy the install command above and run it in your terminal.
Launch Claude Code, Cursor, or your preferred AI coding agent.
Use the prompt template or examples below to test the skill.
Adapt the skill to your specific use case and workflow.
Consult the Marketing Council with [SPECIFIC MARKETING QUESTION OR CHALLENGE]. Gather perspectives from at least three legendary marketers (e.g., Seth Godin, David Ogilvy, Eugene Schwartz, April Dunford, Rory Sutherland, Alex Hormozi, Byron Sharp). Structure the response as a debate or roundtable discussion, highlighting key disagreements, consensus points, and actionable advice. Include [CONTEXT] such as industry, target audience, or campaign details to tailor the advice. Example: 'Consult the Marketing Council on how to reposition a declining SaaS product targeting mid-market enterprises. Include insights from April Dunford (positioning), Rory Sutherland (behavioral economics), and Byron Sharp (brand salience).'
### **Marketing Council Debate: Repositioning 'Flowlytics' for Mid-Market SaaS Enterprises** **Context:** Flowlyytics, a 5-year-old SaaS platform, has seen stagnant growth in the mid-market segment (100–1,000 employees) despite strong enterprise adoption. The product’s core value—real-time analytics for supply chain optimization—is underutilized by smaller teams. The marketing team is debating whether to: 1. **Double down on enterprise case studies** to attract mid-market teams via social proof. 2. **Simplify the messaging** to focus on 'cost savings' rather than 'supply chain resilience.' 3. **Launch a freemium tier** to lower the barrier to entry. --- **April Dunford (Positioning Expert):** 'Flowlytics isn’t just another analytics tool—it’s a *supply chain command center*. Mid-market teams often underestimate their supply chain risks because they lack the resources to model them. Your messaging should emphasize *risk mitigation*, not cost savings. Case studies from similar-sized companies (e.g., a regional manufacturer) would resonate more than enterprise examples. Freemium? Only if the free tier delivers *immediate* value—like a 30-day supply chain health audit. Otherwise, you’re training users to expect free forever.' **Rory Sutherland (Behavioral Economist):** 'The problem isn’t the product—it’s the *framing*. Mid-market buyers are paralyzed by choice. Instead of leading with features, lead with *regret minimization*. Ask: "What’s the cost of *not* optimizing your supply chain?" Use loss aversion language in ads: "Your competitors are cutting costs by 15%—are you?" Ogilvy would call this *emotional leverage*. Also, freemium works if you design the onboarding to *fail fast*—show users a glimpse of their supply chain inefficiencies, then upsell the full solution.' **Byron Sharp (Brand Salience Expert):** 'You’re overcomplicating this. Mid-market buyers don’t care about your *positioning*—they care about *familiarity*. Run ads in *IndustryWeek* and *Supply Chain Dive* with the same headline: "Supply Chain Analytics That Actually Work." Repeat it until they associate Flowlytics with *reliability*. Ogilvy’s rule: "The more you tell, the more you sell." So tell them *exactly* what you do—no jargon. And for God’s sake, stop using the word "resilience"—it’s meaningless to them.' **Alex Hormozi (Growth Expert):** 'You’re leaving money on the table. Mid-market teams *will* pay if you remove friction. Here’s the playbook: 1. **Freemium tier**: Offer a 14-day trial with *one* critical feature (e.g., demand forecasting). Gate the rest behind a paywall. 2. **Social proof**: Partner with a mid-market trade association to host a webinar: "How [Company X] Saved $2M/Year with Flowlytics." 3. **Upsell path**: After the trial, send an automated email: "Your forecast shows a 12% risk of stockouts. Upgrade to Flowlytics Pro to avoid it." Ogilvy would hate the automation, but Hormozi loves the math: 3% conversion on 10,000 trials = 300 new customers.' **Eugene Schwartz (Copywriter):** 'The debate is moot if your messaging doesn’t match the *stage* of awareness. Mid-market buyers aren’t aware they have a supply chain problem—they think it’s just "inventory management." Your ads should educate first: "Did you know 60% of mid-market companies overstock inventory? Flowlytics fixes it in 48 hours." Ogilvy would call this *problem-awareness copy*. Once they’re aware, then hit them with the freemium offer.' --- **Consensus Points:** - **Messaging**: Focus on *risk mitigation* (Dunford) and *regret minimization* (Sutherland), not cost savings. - **Channels**: Trade publications (Sharp) + webinars (Hormozi). - **Tactics**: Freemium tier (Hormozi) with *immediate* value (Dunford). **Actionable Next Steps:** 1. **This week**: Draft 3 ad variations using Schwartz’s problem-awareness copy. Test headlines like: - "Is Your Supply Chain Costing You $1M/Year?" - "60% of Mid-Market Companies Overstock Inventory—Are You?" 2. **Next 30 days**: Partner with a mid-market trade group for a webinar. Use Dunford’s positioning framework to refine the pitch. 3. **Ongoing**: A/B test freemium vs. trial offers. Track conversion rates and average deal size. **Key Disagreement:** - **Freemium vs. Trial**: Hormozi and Dunford favor freemium (with strict value gates), while Sharp argues for pure trial-based upsells. Test both. **Final Thought (Seth Godin):** 'Marketing isn’t about selling a product—it’s about selling a *transformation*. Flowlytics isn’t a tool; it’s a *safety net* for mid-market teams. Show them the fall they avoided, and they’ll pay to keep it.'
skills-collection
Take a free 3-minute scan and get personalized AI skill recommendations.
Take free scan